Yin et al. (2026) Dual-season hotspots concentrate diagnosed agricultural water pressure in the North China Plain
Identification
- Journal: Agricultural Water Management
- Year: 2026
- Date: 2026-11-10
- Authors: Wen Yin, Pan Li, Jingui Wei, Matthew Tom Harrison, Hailong Qiu, Feier Wang, Xinyuan Ma, Lianhao Zhao, Pingxing Wan, Ke Liu, Zhilong Fan, FaLong Hu, Yunyou Nan, Qiang Chai
- DOI: 10.1016/j.agwat.2026.110934
Research Groups
- State Key Laboratory of Aridland Crop Science, College of Agronomy, Gansu Agricultural University, Lanzhou, China
- Tasmanian Institute of Agriculture, University of Tasmania, Launceston, Tasmania, Australia
Short Summary
This study developed an environmental pressure index (EPI) for the North China Plain, integrating remote-sensing and climate data to assess agricultural water pressure. It found that high pressure is concentrated in dual-season hotspots (spring and summer) covering a small area but containing most high-EPI regions, occurring across varying productivity levels.
Objective
- To examine the hypothesis that agricultural water pressure is concentrated in particular cropland areas and seasons, which annual regional averages may obscure.
- To identify where and in which seasons pressure is concentrated, and if these locations are repeatedly affected.
- To determine whether high pressure accompanies higher or lower agricultural productivity.
- To assess how changes in climate and water use affect the extent of high-pressure cropland and average regional pressure.
Study Configuration
- Spatial Scale: Rectangular domain 112–121°E and 32–41°N, covering the North China Plain and adjacent areas. Analysis domain comprised 1,630,553 cropland grid cells, each approximately 0.1885–0.2114 square kilometers in area, derived from a nominal 500-meter export grid.
- Temporal Scale: 5-year period (2020–2024), with seasonal windows defined as March–June (spring), July–September (summer), and March–October (full growing season).
Methodology and Data
- Models used:
- Environmental Pressure Index (EPI): A diagnostic index integrating five normalized components: water consumption (evapotranspiration, ET), precipitation deficit, low water-use efficiency (WUE), moisture stress, and temperature exposure.
- Management Zoning: Rule-based classification of cropland into five zones based on EPI, productivity benefit (PB), moisture stress (M), and climate exposure (CE).
- Seasonal ET/P ratio analysis: Used to identify periods of water imbalance.
- Scenario Assessment: Rule-based perturbations applied to inputs to test changes in EPI and high-EPI area under targeted water-saving, low-WUE, drought-warming, and combined conditions.
- Sensitivity Analysis: Tested alternative weighting schemes, component removals, and spatial-block resampling for robustness.
- Data sources: Public remote-sensing, climate, and land-cover products, primarily via Google Earth Engine.
- MODIS ET (MOD16A2GF): Evapotranspiration, 500 meters, 8-day, 2020–2024 (annual and seasonal sums, in meters).
- MODIS GPP (MOD17A2HGF): Gross Primary Productivity, 500 meters, 8-day, 2020–2024 (annual sums, in kilograms of carbon per square meter).
- CHIRPS P: Precipitation, 0.05 degrees (nominal 5-kilometer export), daily, 2020–2024 (annual and seasonal sums, in meters).
- ERA5-Land Air temperature: Air temperature (temperature_2m), 0.1 degrees (nominal 11.132-kilometer export), 2020–2024 (annual mean, in degrees Celsius).
- SMAP L4 Surface SM: Surface Soil Moisture (0–5 cm), 9-kilometer native product, 3-hourly, 2020–2024 (March–October mean, in cubic meters per cubic meter).
- ESA WorldCover (v200): Cropland Map, 10 meters, 2021.
- Winter wheat map (Liu et al., 2024): Binary wheat map, 30 meters, 2020.
- Agricultural water use (Fang and Liu, 2024): Gross agricultural withdrawal, administrative totals, annual, 2020–2022.
Main Results
- High-EPI cells (EPI > 0.67) occupied 2.06% of analyzed grid-cell area.
- Dual-season hotspots (high spring and summer ET/P) covered 7.36% of analyzed area but contained 82.57% of high-EPI area, representing an 11.22-fold enrichment.
- 46.88% of high-EPI area fell below the productivity benefit (PB) threshold of 0.60, indicating high pressure in both higher- and lower-productivity cropland.
- Full-growing-season ET/P showed the strongest pixelwise correlation with baseline EPI (r = 0.764) and highest separation of high-EPI cells (ROC-AUC = 0.996).
- Wheat-dominated cropland (≥50% winter-wheat cover) exhibited a higher mean spring ET/P of 1.134 compared to 0.799 in other cropland.
- Only 18.44% of the mean dual-season hotspot footprint recurred in at least four out of five years, despite annual dual-season sets consistently concentrating high EPI.
- Scenario analysis revealed that proportional changes in high-EPI area were 8.88 to 15.09 times larger than corresponding changes in mean EPI. For example, in scenario S4, mean EPI remained elevated while hotspot area fell below baseline, depending on evapotranspiration assumptions.
- Spatial ranking of EPI was robust (Pearson spatial correlations ≥ 0.935 under alternative weighting schemes), but hotspot membership was more sensitive to component removal (area-weighted Jaccard overlap ranged from 0.492 to 0.781).
- A weak positive rank correlation (Spearman ρ = 0.308) was observed between mean EPI and agricultural withdrawal across 58 administrative units (2020–2022).
Contributions
- Connects agricultural water pressure concentration with seasonal timing, productivity context, and regional change, providing a basis for targeted monitoring and assessment of water-saving options.
- Introduces a joint diagnosis framework that distinguishes high pressure accompanying higher productivity from that accompanying lower productivity, and spring-only imbalance from dual-season imbalance.
- Demonstrates that changes in hotspot extent and regional mean pressure can respond differently to perturbations, emphasizing the need to report both for comprehensive assessment.
- Provides a temporally consistent, open-data workflow for diagnosing agricultural water pressure in multi-cropping systems.
Funding
- Scientific Research Innovation Capability Support Project for Young Faculty (SRICSPYF-BS2025119)
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (32372238 and 32460547)
- Science and Technology Program of Gansu Province (26ZDNA001 and 24ZDNA008)
- Gansu Youth Science and Technology Key Research Project (GQK2024030)
Citation
@article{Yin2026Dualseason,
author = {Yin, Wen and Li, Pan and Wei, Jingui and Harrison, Matthew Tom and Qiu, Hailong and Wang, Feier and Ma, Xinyuan and Zhao, Lianhao and Wan, Pingxing and Liu, Ke and Fan, Zhilong and Hu, FaLong and Nan, Yunyou and Chai, Qiang},
title = {Dual-season hotspots concentrate diagnosed agricultural water pressure in the North China Plain},
journal = {Agricultural Water Management},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1016/j.agwat.2026.110934},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2026.110934}
}
Original Source: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2026.110934